The Dark Night of the Soul? Or Just the Ego Throwing a Tantrum?

The spiritual marketplace loves its poetry.

The "Dark Night of the Soul" sells better than "ego death panic," though they're the same damn thing. St. John coined the term, and spiritual seekers have been wearing it like a badge of honor ever since – proof they're on the path, evidence they've paid the cosmic toll.

I had my Dark Night. Twelve years of abject despair. Lost my marriage, my kids, my job, my home. Nearly ended it all. But was this some divinely ordained trial? A spiritual crucible designed by the universe to test my mettle?

No. It was my ego throwing the mother of all tantrums as its foundations began to crack. A toddler realizing its favorite toy is being taken away. This isn't some noble spiritual passage...

...it's the death throes of illusion.

The Self Losing Its World

The self doesn't surrender; it implodes in spectacular fashion.

From a nondual perspective, what most call the Dark Night is simply what happens when the illusion of self begins to thin but hasn't fully dissolved. It's the gap between worlds – the old dream fading, the new reality not yet stabilized. The terror comes not from darkness, but from light breaking through the cracks.

You've had glimpses, haven't you? Moments where reality felt different, less personal. Where the boundaries between "you" and "everything else" blurred. The self tasted something beyond its confines and now can't un-know what it knows. But that self – that deeply ingrained habit of identification – won't pack its bags and leave without a fight. The more it feels threatened, the harder it clings. The harder it clings, the more it suffers.

This suffering isn't punishment or test – it's friction. The friction of an illusion trying to maintain itself against the sandpaper of truth. The ego's world is collapsing, and with it goes all meaning, purpose, and identity it constructed.

What you experience as emptiness is just the absence of falsehood…

…and nothing hurts like seeing through your own bullshit.

The Mechanism of Suffering

Your darkness is resistance, not revelation.

The suffering of the Dark Night doesn't come from the awakening process itself but from fighting against it. Like a drowning person whose struggle only ensures they sink faster, the ego's desperate attempts to reassert itself intensify the very disintegration it fears.

Picture a man who's lived his entire life in an elaborate theater production. He's memorized his lines, earned applause, formed relationships with fellow actors. Then one day, he glimpses the edge of the stage, sees the scaffolding behind the set. That first glimpse changes everything. He keeps forgetting his lines. The props look fake. The emotional scenes feel hollow. His fellow actors seem mechanical. The play that once felt so real now feels absurd, yet he doesn't know how to stop performing.

This in-between state – neither fully identified with the character nor fully free of it – creates unbearable tension. The ego knows it's dying but can't accept it. It knows the play is fake but can't stop acting. It senses freedom beyond the stage but fears there's nothing there.

The very resistance intended to preserve the self accelerates its dissolution…

…like squeezing sand only makes it slip through your fingers faster.

The Illusion of Meaning

Purpose is the ego's favorite security blanket.

What hurts most during the Dark Night isn't just losing your sense of self, but losing all the meaning that self created. The universe suddenly seems cold, indifferent. God goes silent. Spiritual practices feel empty. The path disappears.

This isn't because meaning has been taken from you – it's because you're seeing that the meaning was yours all along, projected onto reality like shadows on a wall. Consider the devoted monk who after decades of prayer stops feeling God's presence. Or the dedicated meditator who can no longer find peace in practice. Or the spiritual seeker who suddenly can't remember why awakening mattered in the first place. Each is experiencing the collapse of a meaning structure – a story the self told to make sense of existence.

Reality needs no meaning; it just is. The self needs meaning to survive. When meaning collapses, the self feels the full terror of its own contingency. Its foundations aren't built on bedrock but on a house of cards it constructed itself. The panic isn't about losing God or purpose or direction – it's about losing the illusion that these things exist independently of the self that imagined them.

The Dark Night strips away not just who you think you are…

…but every reason you thought you had for being anything at all.

Moving Through, Not Around

Stop looking for the emergency exit.

The instinct during the Dark Night is to escape – find a new teacher, a new practice, a new belief system to make the pain stop. This is like changing theaters while remaining an actor. The scenery changes, but the fundamental illusion persists.

The way out isn't around but through. Through the disintegration, through the meaninglessness, through the terror of non-existence. I've watched seekers try everything to escape their Dark Night. Ayahuasca ceremonies. Silent retreats. New gurus. Ancient texts. More meditation. Less meditation. All of it attempting to rebuild what's crumbling. All of it missing the point entirely. The crumbling is the path. The disintegration is the liberation. The not-knowing is the arrival.

The most valuable thing you can do in this darkness is simple yet brutal: stop fighting. Stop seeking rescue. Stop romanticizing your suffering as spiritual achievement. Turn toward the sufferer instead. Who exactly is experiencing this despair? Who feels lost? Who craves meaning?

Investigate the one who suffers until you see through the illusion of the separate self that seems to be having this experience. When identification with the sufferer drops away…

…you'll find the darkness was just the space where your illusions used to be.

The Ultimate Disillusionment

This isn't a tunnel; it's an unveiling.

What you call the Dark Night isn't darkness at all – it's disillusionment in its most literal sense: the removal of illusion. What feels like loss is actually liberation. What feels like death is the dying of what was never alive to begin with – the conceptual self, the narrative "I" with its story of past and future.

Your ego frames this as a catastrophe, a cosmic abandonment, a night that might never end. But in those moments when resistance drops – even for a second – you might glimpse that this darkness isn't the absence of light but the absence of filters that once distorted your vision. The world isn't growing darker; your capacity to see clearly is growing stronger.

Every mystic, sage, and awakened teacher throughout history had to pass through this territory. Not as a test of worthiness but as the natural consequence of seeing through the fundamental delusion at the core of human experience.

The difference between those who awaken and those who remain asleep isn't that some are spared this process – it's that some are willing to let it complete itself. When the last illusion falls away...

...the darkness reveals itself as the light you've been seeking all along.

---